The 'King' of Australian coin rarities
The Proof 1930 Penny is so much more than our most valuable Australian penny.
It also is the most expensive Australian coin. Of any metal.
That is a prize title when you consider that Australia has struck millions upon millions of coins in different metals, including copper with pennies and halfpennies minted between 1911 and 1964. And silver, with the threepence, sixpence, shilling and florin struck between 1910 and 1964. And Australians enjoyed the luxury of a gold coinage in the sovereign and half sovereign struck between 1855 and 1931.
The most recent sale of a Proof 1930 Penny was in March 2019 for $1.15 million.
The price claimed a new record. The most expensive Australian penny. And the most expensive Australian coin.
How many Proof 1930 Pennies exist?
The Melbourne Mint officially recorded its striking of six Proof 1930 Pennies. So where are they today?
Three are held by private collectors, one in Melbourne with the remaining two in Sydney.
Three are held in public institutions, the British Museum, the Museum of Victoria and the Art Gallery of South Australia.
The pathway to becoming the most valuable Australian penny
Coinworks Managing Director, Belinda Downie, celebrated the purchase and sale of her first Proof 1930 Penny in 1997.
The coin was acquired at a Melbourne public auction and later sold to the owner of the Madrid Collection of Australian Rare Coins for $147,500. Now in a retirement phase, the owner is relinquishing his prized possession and has consigned the coin to Coinworks to offer in 2021. Stay tuned!
A second Proof 1930 Penny surfaced in 1999. It's background is interesting. In 1962 the British Museum received a donation of a Proof 1930 Penny. It was their second Proof '30, the Museum having been gifted one by the Melbourne Mint soon after it was struck.
Two decades later, the British Museum decided that two Proof 1930 Pennies were surplus to their requirements and exchanged one of their Proof '30s for an 1852 Cracked Die Adelaide Pound.
The exchange occurred between the British Museum and a Sydney based Auction House. The Auction House sold the Proof 1930 Penny by private treaty to a local collector for a figure reputed to be $150,000.
The British Museum Duplicate Proof 1930 Penny came onto the open market at auction in 1999.
Acting on the instructions of a Victorian buyer the coin was acquired by Coinworks for $258,750. The same coin came back into Coinworks hands in 2005, when it was sold to a Sydney family for $620,000.
This Proof 1930 Penny, the former property of the British Museum, was the most recent transaction of a Proof 1930 Penny, selling in March 2019 for $1.15 million.
Belinda Downie sold the third Proof 1930 Penny in 2011 for $1.05 million. This example had a long and exemplary history having been owned by one of the industry’s great collectors and a pioneer of the rare coin industry, Syd Hagley. In an interview conducted late in 2010, a colleague of Hagley recalled being offered the coin for just £300 in 1964. He declined the offer simply because he could not afford it at the time.
His misfortune became clear in 1974 when the coin sold at auction in Los Angeles for $16,000 as part of the famed Dr Paxman Collection. The under bidder at the time, now retired rare coin dealer Laurie Nugent, still recalls his bitter disappointment at missing out on the famous penny. He eventually acquired it in 1981.
In 1982, the Proof 1930 Penny’s star status was confirmed when Australian nursing home magnate Doug Moran bought it for a reported $100,000. For Moran, it was a matter of national pride – he declared that the coin was so important it should never leave Australian shores.
The Hagley specimen was offered at public auction in 2000, where it was picked up by a Melbourne collector for $281,750. In 2011, Coinworks was commissioned to sell the coin privately. The sale was completed in that year for $1.05 million.
The media always refers to the Proof 1930 Penny as the ‘King’ of Australian coin rarities. And with good reason. It is our most valuable coin.
But there is more to the Proof 1930 Penny that its value. The coin generates a strong emotional attachment that goes far beyond its numismatic worth.
As the nation's most valuable coin, the Proof 1930 Penny inspires a feeling of national pride in Australians from all walks of life. It is the nation's very own 'million-dollar' penny and every Australian somehow seems connected to it.
We have only seen such an intense connection with one other product. And that was the Commonwealth of Australia’s first banknote, with the serial number '000001'.
And the connection is summed up in two words. ‘National pride’.